Should you use Vivado HLS or SDSoC for Algorithm Implementation and Acceleration in Embedded Systems?

2017年8月25日 | By News | Filed in: News.


By Anthony Boorsma, DornerWorks


Having some trouble choosing between Vivado HLS and SDSoC? Here’s some advice from DornerWorks, a Premier Xilinx Alliance Program member. This blog is adapted from a recent post on the DornerWorks Web site titled “Algorithm Implementation and Acceleration on Embedded Systems



How does an engineer already experienced and comfortable with working in the Zynq SoC’s software-based PS (processing system) domain take advantage of the additional flexibility and processing power of the Zynq SoC’s PL (programmable logic)? The traditional method is through education and training to learn to program the PL using an HDL such as Verilog or VHDL. Another way is to learn and use a tool that allows you to take a software-based design written exclusively for the ARM 32-bit processors in the PS and transfer some or most of the tasks to the PL, without writing HDL descriptions.


One such tool is Xilinx’s Vivado High Level Synthesis (HLS). By leveraging the capabilities of HLS, you can prototype a design using the Zynq PS and then move functionality to the PL to boost performance. The advantage of this tool is that it generates IP blocks that can be used in the programmable logic of Xilinx FPGAs as well as Xilinx Zynq SoCs and Zynq UltraScale+ MPSoCs.


Logic optimization occurs when Vivado HLS synthesizes your algorithm’s C model and creates RTL. There are code directives (essentially guidelines for the tools’ optimization process) available that allow you to guide the HLS tool’s synthesis from the C model source to the RTL bitstream programmed into the FPGA. If you are working with an existing algorithm modeled in C, C++, or SystemC and need to implement this algorithm in custom logic for added performance, then HLS is a great tool choice.


However, be aware that the data movers that transfer data between the Zynq PS and the PL must be manually configured for performance when using Vivado HLS. This can become a complicated process when there’s significant data transfer between the domains.


A recent innovation that simplifies data-mover configuration is the development of the Xilinx SDSoC (Software-Defined System on Chip) Development Environment for use with Zynq SoCs and Zynq UltraScale+ MPSoCs. SDSoC builds on Vivado HLS’ capabilities by using HLS to perform the C-to-RTL conversion but with the convenient addition of automatically generated data movers, which greatly simplifies configuring the connection between the software running on the Zynq PS and the accelerated algorithm executing in the Zynq PL. SDSoC also allows you to guide data-mover generation by providing a set of pragmas to make specific data-mover choices. The SDSoC directive pragmas give you control over the automatically generated data movers but still require some minimal manual configuration. Code-directive pragmas for RTL optimization available in Vivado HLS are also available in SDSoC and can be used in tandem with SDSoC pragmas to optimize both the PL algorithm and the automatically generated data movers.


It is possible to disable the SDSoC auto generated data movers and only use the HLS optimizations. Demonstrated below are an IP block diagram generated with the auto configured SDSoC data movers and one without them.


The following screen shots are taken from a Xilinx-provided template project demonstrating the acceleration of a software matrix multiplication and addition algorithm, provided with the SDx installation. We used the SDx 2016.4 toolchain and targeted an Avnet Zedboard with a standalone OS configuration for this example.






Here is a screen shot of the same block, but without the SDSoC data movers. (We have disabled the automatic generation of data movers within SDSoC by manually declaring the AXI HLS interface directives for both mmult and madd accelerated IP block.)






To achieve the best algorithm performance, be prepared to familiarize yourself and use both the SDSoC and Vivado HLS user guides and datasheets. SDSoC provides a superset of Vivado HLS’s capabilities.


If you are developing and accelerating your model from first principles but want to take advantage of the flexibility of testing and proving out a design in software first, and you don’t intend to use a Zynq SoC, then using the Vivado HLS toolset straightaway is the place to start. A design started in HLS is transferable to an SDSoC if requirements change. Alternatively, if using a Zynq-based system is possible, it would be worthwhile to start right away with using SDSoC.





via Xcell Daily Blog articles

August 22, 2017 at 04:57AM


电子邮件地址不会被公开。 必填项已用*标注